Year 11 · Original DASKEREL study pack · Academic review pending
Iterate a design from test evidence
Allow up to 55 minutes for reading, practice and review · Source route: Oak KS4 design and technology; board-neutral preparation
DASKEREL wrote this resource using the Oak National Academy unit sequence as a curriculum reference. It is a study pack, not a complete unit or an exam-board-approved course. Academic review remains pending.
You will learn to
- Create a testable prototype hypothesis.
- Distinguish test results from interpretation and recommend a controlled change.
- Document an iteration that can be compared fairly with the first prototype.
Key terms: iteration · prototype · variable · criterion · feedback · evidence
Learn the idea
Iteration is a loop of making a candidate, testing it against criteria, interpreting the evidence and changing the design. It is not simply redrawing the same concept more neatly. Start with a problem statement and one measurable criterion. For a tabletop reading stand, the criterion might be that the stand holds a specified book at two agreed angles without sliding on the test surface. Record the book mass, surface and angle; otherwise a later test is hard to compare.
A prototype isolates a design idea. A card mock-up can test reach and geometry before a stronger material is selected. When the first version fails, describe the failure precisely: 'the rear support slips after 20 seconds at the steeper angle' is actionable; 'it looks weak' is not. If you change the support angle and add a rubber pad simultaneously, you cannot tell which change helped. Test one change where practical, then keep the same load and method.
User feedback can reveal requirements a bench test misses, such as difficulty folding the stand. Seek consent and ask neutral questions rather than 'isn't this better?'. Record the user's comment alongside objective measurements; one opinion is not proof for all users. Annotate version numbers, dimensions and reasons for decisions. Any manufacturing, tool use and assessed GCSE non-exam work require centre supervision, authenticity controls and the chosen board's current rules.
Worked example
A card reading stand holds a 0.8 kg book at 30° but slides at 45° on a smooth desk after 20 seconds. Plan a fair next iteration.
- Record the original base width, support angle, desk surface, book mass and time to slide.
- Hypothesise that increasing the rear support footprint will improve stability at 45°.
- Make version 2 with only that footprint change; keep the same card, book, desk and 45° test.
- Repeat the test and record time to slide, then compare with 20 seconds before deciding whether the change worked.
A traceable one-variable change makes the comparison more informative; it does not guarantee the stand is safe for general use.
Try together
A prototype holder is hard for one user to fold. Write a neutral feedback question and one measurable follow-up test.
- Avoid suggesting the answer in the question.
- Choose a repeatable task and record conditions.
Show guided answer
Ask: 'Which step in folding the holder was difficult, and why?' Then time a clearly defined folding task over repeated supervised trials with the same setup, recording errors as well as time.
Practise independently
- Why change only one design variable in the first retest when possible?
Show answer and reasoning for question 1
It helps attribute any changed result to the modified feature. Changing several features together makes causal interpretation weaker.
- Separate the observation and interpretation in 'the stand slipped because the base is too narrow'.
Show answer and reasoning for question 2
Observation: the stand slipped under stated test conditions. Interpretation: a narrow base may be a cause, which needs a test. A proposed cause is not yet established by a single observation.
- Name two conditions that must stay constant when comparing two stand versions.
Show answer and reasoning for question 3
For example, the same book mass and desk surface (also angle, test duration and loading position). Comparable conditions make the iteration evidence more meaningful.
DASKEREL exam-style practice · 5 draft marks
This original practice task and guidance are not an official examination-board paper or mark scheme.
A first prototype fails a stability test. Propose a controlled revision, explain how you would compare it with the first, and state one limitation. This is DASKEREL written practice, not a centre-authenticated NEA mark scheme.
Show draft mark guidance
- 1 practice point: states the observed failure with test conditions.
- 1 practice point: proposes a plausible single-feature change and reason.
- 1 practice point: defines a repeatable success criterion.
- 1 practice point: keeps relevant test conditions comparable.
- 1 practice point: evaluates a limitation or further user/safety test.
Check your understanding
- A new drawing without test evidence is not a demonstrated improvement.
- A user's preference and a measured result answer different questions.
- A successful small prototype test does not certify the final product's safety.
Retrieve later: Describe the four steps of an evidence-led iteration, then separate one observed failure from its possible cause.
Next step: Build a version log with photos or sketches, dimensions, test results and decisions under the centre's practical and NEA rules.
Library links: Oak National Academy · Iterative Design Principles (checked 2026-11-07) · DASKEREL subject library. Oak's applicable post-2022 content licence is OGL v3.0; some source assets have separate third-party rights. No Oak media is embedded here. DASKEREL is not affiliated with Oak.