Year 10 · Original DASKEREL study pack · Academic review pending
Compare two non-fiction voices without losing the writers' purposes
Allow up to 55 minutes for reading, practice and review · Source route: Oak AQA English Language
DASKEREL wrote this resource using the Oak National Academy unit sequence as a curriculum reference. It is a study pack, not a complete unit or an exam-board-approved course. Academic review remains pending.
You will learn to
- Identify each writer's claim, audience and purpose
- Compare methods and effects through precise paired evidence
- Write a comparative paragraph that explains a meaningful difference
Key terms: viewpoint · register · rhetorical question · comparison · qualification
Learn the idea
A comparison begins with what the writers think, not with a list of techniques. Ask: what judgement does each writer want the reader to reach? A campaigner might seek reform; a reporter might explain a disputed policy. Both can describe the same event while selecting different details.
Purpose shapes register. A formal report may use measured verbs and statistics; an open letter may address its audience directly and use questions to provoke a response. Name the specific choice, quote or describe it accurately, and explain how that choice serves the writer's purpose.
Compare like with like. Pair the writers' treatment of one issue, such as safety, cost or fairness. A strong comparison uses a connective such as 'whereas', but the reasoning after it matters more: explain how each method positions the reader.
When a source offers a counterargument, do not flatten it into a single opinion. A qualified claim can concede a problem before proposing a remedy. That concession may make the writer seem reasonable rather than uncertain.
Worked example
Invented Source A says, 'A warning should help a young person change course, not close every door.' Invented Source B says, 'The scheme's costs rose by 18% while repeat incidents fell by only 2%.' Compare their approaches to a youth support scheme.
- Source A argues for a rehabilitative response. 'Help' and 'change course' present the young person as capable of improvement.
- Source B tests effectiveness through two figures. The contrast between rising cost and small reduction invites scepticism about value.
- Join the ideas: while A appeals to fairness and possibility, B frames the issue as a measurable policy outcome.
- Explain the likely audiences cautiously: A could persuade a community audience; B could inform readers judging public expenditure. The wording supports these inferences, but no audience is explicitly named.
Both discuss the same scheme, yet A asks the reader to value second chances whereas B asks whether the results justify the cost.
Try together
Source C: 'Every street deserves to feel safe.' Source D: 'Recorded incidents declined, although residents still report feeling unsafe.' Compare how certainty is used.
- Underline the absolute term in C.
- Find the concession in D.
- Explain why feelings and recorded incidents are different kinds of evidence.
Show guided answer
C's 'every' makes a confident moral claim about shared safety. D qualifies a positive statistic with 'although', showing that lower recorded incidents do not settle residents' experience.
Practise independently
- What is the main difference between Source A's and Source B's evidence?
Show answer and reasoning for question 1
A uses an ethical appeal to change and opportunity; B uses numerical outcomes and cost. A comparison identifies the kinds of support and connects each to purpose.
- Rewrite 'A is emotional but B uses statistics' as a precise comparative sentence.
Show answer and reasoning for question 2
A's image of a young person changing course encourages hope, whereas B's cost and incident figures invite readers to question the scheme's effectiveness. The revision identifies the actual choices and their possible effects.
- Why would 'both writers completely disagree' be too strong?
Show answer and reasoning for question 3
They may both value safety or improvement; the short extracts show different emphases, not every belief either writer holds. Inference should be limited to available evidence.
DASKEREL exam-style practice · 4 draft marks
This original practice task and guidance are not an official examination-board paper or mark scheme.
Using Sources A and B above, compare how the writers present the value of the youth support scheme. Use evidence from both invented sources.
Show draft mark guidance
- 1 DASKEREL practice point: clear comparison of attitudes to the same scheme
- 1 practice point: accurate selection of evidence from both sources
- 1 practice point: explanation of language or numerical methods and reader effect
- 1 practice point: sustained, qualified interpretation rather than unsupported claims
Check your understanding
- A connective alone does not make a developed comparison.
- A statistic needs interpretation and cannot prove a policy succeeds or fails on its own.
- Do not infer the writer's identity or full political view from two sentences.
Retrieve later: Without notes, state the four moves in a comparison: viewpoint, paired evidence, method and effect.
Next step: Compare two complete non-fiction texts, then test whether the opening judgement still holds after reading their conclusions.
Library links: Oak National Academy · Non-fiction: crime and punishment (checked 2026-11-06) · DASKEREL subject library. Oak's applicable post-2022 content licence is OGL v3.0; some source assets have separate third-party rights. No Oak media is embedded here. DASKEREL is not affiliated with Oak.